Guild Manager vs Throney
Throney is a Throne and Liberty focused, Discord-first guild tool. It is cheaper than Guild Manager at $7.50 per month, and if you run a single Throne and Liberty guild and want everything inside Discord, it is a reasonable choice.
CoGM says it is the team behind Throney. If you are comparing Guild Manager, Throney, and CoGM, you are comparing two products from the same team.
Throney publishes a comparison page about Guild Manager. Several of its claims are inaccurate, and we have corrected them below with specifics rather than adjectives.
Side by side
| Feature | Guild Manager | Throney |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly price | $19.99 for up to 4 guilds | $7.50Throney is cheaper. If price decides it, they win this row. |
| Free tier | Unlimited members | Under 20 players |
| Discord bot | 14 global slash commands, role sync, reminders, gear checks | Discord-native |
| Web application | Full web app | Discord-first |
| Mobile access | iPhone beta waitlist | No verified native app listing |
| Multi-game support | Multiple games with per-game configuration | Listed as coming soon |
| DKP and contribution metrics | Included on paid plans | Included |
| Voice attendance | Manual or scheduled voice snapshots | Included |
| Alliances | Up to 8 guilds per alliance | 4 guilds |
Choose Throney if
- Throne and Liberty is the only game you play and you want the lowest monthly price.
- You want members to interact only through Discord commands.
- You do not need multi-game support, which Throney's own comparison table lists as coming soon.
Choose Guild Manager if
- You run more than one game, or expect to when your guild moves.
- You want a full web application alongside the Discord bot.
- You need alliances across multiple guilds, applications, and a retained decision history.
Corrections
Throney publishes a comparison page about Guild Manager. These claims are inaccurate as of 2026-08-24.
- Guild Manager's Discord integration is "Limited".
- Guild Manager ships 14 global Discord slash commands, plus role synchronisation, activity announcements and reminders, application notifications, and gear checks run from Discord.
- Guild Manager is for people who "prefer web-only tools".
- Guild Manager has a Discord bot and a full web application. Its iPhone app is in a small TestFlight beta, so it is not a general-availability advantage yet.
- Guild Manager's comparison rows for DKP, voice attendance, and alliance support are left blank or marked as varying.
- All three are shipped features. Guild Manager includes DKP and custom contribution metrics, manual or scheduled voice attendance snapshots, and alliances of up to 8 guilds.
- Guild Manager's free tier is "Varies".
- Guild Manager's free plan is one guild with unlimited members.
Common questions
- Which one is cheaper?
- Guild Manager Free includes one guild with unlimited members. Core costs $19.99 per month and includes up to four guilds. CoGM Pro is $10 per guild each month and Throney is $7.50 per month, so both cost less for one guild. Core costs less than separate CoGM Pro subscriptions once you need two to four guilds. Guild Manager also has a full web application, a Discord bot, and an iPhone beta waitlist.
- Is Throney the same company as CoGM?
- CoGM says it is the team behind Throney. CoGM runs as the multi-game platform and Throney as the Throne and Liberty brand.
- Does Guild Manager work inside Discord?
- Yes. Guild Manager ships 14 global Discord slash commands covering activities, announcements, gear, profiles, leave of absence, rewards, and looking for group, along with Discord role synchronisation, activity reminders, and application notifications. Throney's comparison page describes this as limited, which is not accurate.
- Does Guild Manager support Throne and Liberty specifically?
- Yes. Guild Manager carries Throne and Liberty class and weapon configuration, gear tracking, and a set of free community tools including PvP rankings and gear utilities, alongside support for other games on the same roster model.