GuildManager vs ForeverDB for WoW Forever guilds
ForeverDB combines a WoW Forever database with free raid sign-ups, reserves, reminders and guild websites.
GuildManager Free supports one guild with unlimited members, public Battle.net guild sync and addon raid logs. Core is $19.99 a month, or $14.99 a month billed yearly, for up to 4 guilds, and adds DKP, loot council voting, recurring raid nights and reminders.
. View sources.
Start Free with Battle.net or addon roster sync, soft reserves and raid reports. Core adds DKP, loot council voting and activity automation.
What your officers can do
A roster that keeps itself current. Free.
Link your guild's public Battle.net guild while creating it or in Game settings. Levels, classes and races sync every few hours, including members who never install an addon, and gear, talents and professions come from public character profiles.
See WoW Forever roster syncCompare candidates before voting. Core.
Bring saved attendance, points, wishlists and recent awards into your council's decision. Each account gets one vote, and officers can leave a note explaining the award.
See the loot council workflowEvery WoW Forever workflow, row by row
Comparing more than two tools? Our WoW Forever page sets GuildManager next to CoGM on pricing, the addon, reserves, DKP and attendance, with each competitor claim linked to its source.
Compare WoW Forever guild toolsSide by side
GuildManager and ForeverDB feature comparison
Price
- GuildManager
- Free for one guild. Core $19.99 / month for up to 4 guilds
- ForeverDB
- Free. Its guilds page answers "Is it free?" with "Yes, all of it."
Members
- GuildManager
- Unlimited on every plan
- ForeverDB
- No member limit stated on the pages we checked
Roster source
- GuildManager
- Your guild's public Battle.net roster every few hours, or the in-game roster through the addon and desktop app
- ForeverDB
- Members' addon uploads. The Guild Master's upload claims the guild, and verified members' rosters confirm everyone else
Character gear
- GuildManager
- Gear, stats, talents and professions from public Battle.net profiles; the addon also shares them between guildmates in game
- ForeverDB
- Gear, talents, professions, reputations and readiness from members who switch on sharing with the guild
Raid calendar
- GuildManager
- One-off activities and RSVP on Free. Recurring raid nights, reminders and advanced party planning on Core
- ForeverDB
- One-off or weekly events with role limits and a waitlist, Discord webhook and email reminders, and private calendar feeds
Soft and hard reserves
- GuildManager
- Soft reserves on Free, with locking and amendments; the addon shows soft and hard reserves on tooltips. Classic Era item catalog for now
- ForeverDB
- Per event from its loot tables, with officer-set counts, hard reserves, +1s and an attendance bonus; its addon shows reserves on tooltips
DKP, council and auctions
- GuildManager
- DKP, loot council voting and Discord auctions on Core
- ForeverDB
- A loot log that shows whether each reserve was honoured. DKP, council voting and auctions are not listed on its guild tools page
Raid records
- GuildManager
- The addon records members, pulls, kills, drops and rolls, and logs from several officers merge into one report
- ForeverDB
- Loot log and attendance from members' Companion uploads and combat logs
Attendance
- GuildManager
- Basic check-in on Free. Discord voice attendance on Core
- ForeverDB
- Attendance over 4 and 12 weeks, with lates and no-shows
Guild website
- GuildManager
- Public guild profile and application workflow
- ForeverDB
- Free public page with banner, recruiting and Apply, raid schedule and progress, on yourguild.foreverdb.net
Games
- GuildManager
- WoW Forever plus other games on the same roster model
- ForeverDB
- Built for WoW Forever
Sources
GuildManager documentation: Discord command guide · voice attendance.
Choose ForeverDB if
- You want recurring raid nights, Discord and email reminders, a waitlist and calendar feeds at no cost. On GuildManager, recurring activities and reminders need Core.
- You want soft reserves on Forever loot tables today. GuildManager's reservation list still uses Classic Era items.
- You want a free public guild website on its own yourguild.foreverdb.net address.
- You want a green, amber or red readiness check for each raider before every event.
Choose GuildManager if
- You want the roster to sync from Battle.net every few hours, without waiting for members to upload.
- You run DKP, loot council votes or loot auctions from Discord, which ForeverDB's guild tools page does not list.
- Several officers record the same raid and you want their logs merged into one report.
- You run more than one game, up to 4 guilds, or an alliance of up to 8 guilds.
- You want a guild bank and treasury ledger next to your loot records.
Corrections
ForeverDB's guild tools page explains its membership checks with one claim that does not match what Blizzard serves today. Checked 2026-11-09.
- It says "WoW Forever has no Battle.net API yet, so ForeverDB can't ask Blizzard."
- Blizzard's Battle.net API returns WoW Forever guild rosters and character profiles. GuildManager has synced linked guilds from it since November 6. ForeverDB's upload-based checks still work; they are a choice, not the only option. Source: ForeverDB guild tools.
Common questions
- Is ForeverDB free?
- Yes. Its guilds page answers "Is it free?" with "Yes, all of it." GuildManager Free is one guild with unlimited members. Core is $19.99 a month, or $14.99 a month billed yearly, for up to 4 guilds.
- Does either one use Battle.net?
- GuildManager does: officers link the guild's public Battle.net guild, the roster syncs every few hours, and gear, talents and professions come from public character profiles. ForeverDB's guild pages say it relies on members' addon uploads instead. GuildManager members can also connect Battle.net and pick their characters; the addon continues recording in-game attendance and loot.
- Which one has DKP and loot council?
- GuildManager Core has DKP, loot council voting with candidate history and Discord auctions. ForeverDB's guild tools page lists soft and hard reserves and a loot log, not DKP, council voting or auctions.
- Which one has a guild website?
- ForeverDB gives every guild a free public page on its own yourguild.foreverdb.net address. GuildManager has a public guild profile with applications, not a custom-address site.