Checked 2026-10-07
WoW Forever guild tools, compared row by row
WoW Forever launches on November 4, 2026 and its first raids, Barrow Deeps (10 players) and Hyjal Summit (20 players), unlock on December 9. Every guild tool now claims WoW Forever support, so this page compares what each one actually publishes.
We read each competitor's public pages on October 7, 2026 and quote them per row. Where a page does not mention a capability we say so rather than guess. Tell us if something changed and we will update the row and the date.
Side by side
Quotes are from each product's own pages on 2026-10-07. “Not mentioned” means the capability does not appear on the pages we checked, not that the product lacks it.
| Capability | Guild ManagerFree with unlimited members. Core $19.99/mo adds loot tools. | CoGMFree up to 30 members per guild. Pro $10/mo per guild. | Guild OrderFrom $3.99/mo (Scout, up to 30 members). No free plan for the owner. | Guild Vault$6.69/mo Standard, $12.72/mo Premium. 14-day trial, no free plan. | OXM.GGPricing not stated on the home page. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Price for the guild owner | Free: one guild, unlimited members, Discord bot, roster, activities, attendance. Core: $19.99/mo for up to 4 guilds, with loot tools, recruitment and alliances. 14-day trial, no card. | Free “30 members per guild”. Pro “$10/mo per guild”, “up to 300 active members per guild, then +200 for $5/month”. 14-day Pro trial.Source: cogm.app | Scout $3.99/mo, “Up to 30 members”; Champion $11.99/mo, up to 200; Legendary $23.99/mo, up to 500. “Guild members always join free”; no free plan for the person running the guild.Source: guildorder.com | “Standard is $6.69/month and includes the full guild suite”; “Premium is $12.72/month and adds Discord bot automation, alliance management, and OCR screenshot import.” 14-day free trial.Source: guildvault.net | Not stated on the home page.Source: oxm.gg |
| WoW Forever status | Live. WoW Forever has its own game configuration, in-game addon, talent calculator and item database. | “World of Warcraft: Forever: In Beta”.Source: cogm.app | Own game page: “Your WoW Forever guild starts here.” Addon announced in the Sep 26, 2026 release “Ready for Launch Night”.Source: guildorder.com | FAQ: “Yes. WoW: Forever guilds can recruit a founding roster, schedule leveling groups, dungeons, and raids”.Source: guildvault.net | “registration open now on forever.oxm.gg ahead of its November 4 launch”.Source: oxm.gg |
| In-game addon | Yes. The desktop app installs and updates the Guild Manager addon. It syncs characters and the guild roster, records raid logs, and shows soft and hard reserves on item tooltips and in loot chat. | Not mentioned on the pages checked.Source: cogm.app | Yes. “The Guild Order addon brings each member's characters to your roster, with no Battle.net link needed.” Profession registry “from the addon or typed in by the member”; the Sep 26 release adds crafting orders, a guild market and leaderboards.Source: guildorder.com | Not mentioned. Roster comes from a Battle.net link instead.Source: guildvault.net | Not mentioned. Loot history imports from RCLootCouncil.Source: oxm.gg |
| Roster import | Officers publish the in-game guild roster from the desktop app; levels and classes update on their own. No Battle.net link needed. | “Roster Management” is listed; an import method is not stated.Source: cogm.app | Addon import, “with no Battle.net link needed”.Source: guildorder.com | “Battle.net can be linked from your profile after sign-in to verify your BattleTag and import WoW characters.”Source: guildvault.net | Character profiles are listed; an import method is not stated.Source: oxm.gg |
| Soft reserves | Yes. Raiders reserve before the raid, the organizer locks the list at the pull, the addon shows soft and hard reserves on tooltips and names them in loot chat. Gargul import and export. | “Wishlists: Members list the drops they want.” Soft reserves are not named on the pages checked.Source: cogm.app | Loot ledger: “Soft reserve, hard reserve, DKP, or EPGP, open today.”Source: guildorder.com | DKP and loot auctions are listed; soft reserves are not named.Source: guildvault.net | “Soft reserves and loot council, with distribution history”.Source: oxm.gg |
| DKP and points | Yes (Core). Attendance rewards, scheduled decay, a full ledger, committed-point protection during auctions, and /rewards add and subtract from Discord. | Pro plan: “DKP & points system”.Source: cogm.app | Loot ledger: “DKP, or EPGP”.Source: guildorder.com | “DKP and loot auctions” in the WoW Forever FAQ answer.Source: guildvault.net | Not named on the home page.Source: oxm.gg |
| Loot auctions run from Discord | Yes (Core). Officers start, bulk-create, award with a required reason, reverse, relist, reopen, hand over and close auctions from Discord; members bid on the Discord post. | Pro plan: “Loot auctions in Discord (WoW Forever, Monsters & Memories)”.Source: cogm.app | Not mentioned on the pages checked.Source: guildorder.com | “loot auctions” listed; Discord bot automation is on Premium.Source: guildvault.net | Not mentioned on the home page.Source: oxm.gg |
| Loot council | Yes (Core). Council votes with one vote per account, candidate comparison (attendance, points, wishlists, recent awards) and a required reason on every award. | Not mentioned on the pages checked.Source: cogm.app | Not mentioned on the pages checked.Source: guildorder.com | Not mentioned on the pages checked.Source: guildvault.net | “Soft reserves and loot council, with distribution history”.Source: oxm.gg |
| Raid logs from the game | Yes. The addon records members, boss pulls and kills, drops and rolls. Guild Manager merges several officers' logs into one raid report and records attendance, DKP and reservation results from it. | “Attendance Tracking” is listed; an in-game raid log is not mentioned.Source: cogm.app | Attendance and a loot ledger are listed; an in-game raid log is not mentioned.Source: guildorder.com | Discord voice attendance is listed; an in-game raid log is not mentioned.Source: guildvault.net | “loot history with RCLootCouncil import”.Source: oxm.gg |
| 10-player and 20-player raid signups | Yes. Barrow Deeps (10) and Hyjal Summit (20) are preconfigured with role targets, waitlists and reusable templates; dungeons, PvP and leveling groups have their own capacities. | “Raid signups: Sign up in Discord or on the site”.Source: cogm.app | “Raid signup: Role quotas today, and the two December 9 raids to come.”Source: guildorder.com | “organize 10-player and 20-player teams”.Source: guildvault.net | “Raid scheduling and multiple splits per night”, “an automatic roster solver for splits”.Source: oxm.gg |
| Professions and crafting orders | Yes. Profession registry from each character's primary and secondary professions, recipe directory and crafting requests in the crafting module. | Not mentioned on the pages checked.Source: cogm.app | “Profession registry: Who crafts what, from the addon or typed in by the member.” Crafting orders and a guild market per the Sep 26 release.Source: guildorder.com | Not mentioned on the pages checked.Source: guildvault.net | Not mentioned on the home page.Source: oxm.gg |
| Guild bank and treasury | Yes (Core). Guild bank with deposits, requests and loot association; a currency treasury with history. | “Guild treasury: Gold and items on request”.Source: cogm.app | “Trade board: Members post spares and wants” and “Contribution ledger: Members log the consumables they turn in toward a goal.”Source: guildorder.com | Not mentioned on the pages checked.Source: guildvault.net | “Guild bank” listed.Source: oxm.gg |
| Voice attendance | Yes, on Free. Manual or scheduled voice snapshots per activity, no-show marking and finalize from /track-activity. | Free plan: “Attendance tracking (Discord voice)”.Source: cogm.app | Every plan: “Discord bot: voice automation, DM reminders, chat bridge”.Source: guildorder.com | “track Discord voice attendance” in the WoW Forever FAQ answer.Source: guildvault.net | Not mentioned on the home page.Source: oxm.gg |
| Discord bot for members | Included on Free: signups, reminders, role sync, /lfg, /apply, /wishlist, /roll, /loot, /attendance, soft-reserve publish and remind. | Free plan: “Discord bot integration”.Source: cogm.app | On every paid plan from $3.99/mo: role sync, scheduled events, polls, voice automation, DM reminders, chat bridge.Source: guildorder.com | “Discord bot automation” is a Premium ($12.72/mo) feature.Source: guildvault.net | “Discord signups and a bot that posts raid embeds”.Source: oxm.gg |
| Alliances | Yes (Core). Up to 8 guilds per alliance with shared activities and attendance. | Not mentioned on the pages checked.Source: cogm.app | Not mentioned on the pages checked.Source: guildorder.com | “alliance management” is a Premium feature.Source: guildvault.net | Not mentioned on the home page.Source: oxm.gg |
What Guild Manager does not do yet
- Battle.net or BattleTag import for WoW Forever. Our roster comes from the addon; Guild Vault offers a Battle.net link.
- Boss assignment sheets and an automatic split-roster solver, which OXM.GG lists.
- Loot tables for Barrow Deeps and Hyjal Summit. Reservation lists use the Classic Era catalog until the raids unlock on December 9 and their loot is confirmed.
- A hosted guild website with a custom subdomain, which Guild Order sells.
Sources
- Pricing · checked 2026-10-07
- WoW Forever addon · checked 2026-10-07
- CoGM home · checked 2026-10-07
- CoGM games · checked 2026-10-07
- CoGM pricing · checked 2026-10-07
- Guild Order WoW Forever · checked 2026-10-07
- Guild Order pricing · checked 2026-10-07
- Guild Order ledger · checked 2026-10-07
- Guild Vault home · checked 2026-10-07
- Guild Vault FAQ · checked 2026-10-07
- OXM.GG home · checked 2026-10-07
Common questions
- Which WoW Forever guild tool shows soft reserves on the item tooltip?
- Guild Manager. Its addon adds “Soft reserved (n): names” and “Hard reserved: name” lines to item tooltips and names reservers in loot chat. Guild Order lists soft and hard reserves in its loot ledger and OXM.GG lists soft reserves, but neither page checked on October 7, 2026 describes an in-game tooltip.
- Which WoW Forever guild tools are free for unlimited members?
- Guild Manager Free has no member cap. CoGM Free allows 30 members per guild, Guild Order has no free plan for the guild owner (members join free), and Guild Vault offers a 14-day trial before $6.69 or $12.72 per month.
- Do I need a Battle.net link to import my WoW Forever roster?
- Not with Guild Manager or Guild Order, which both import from an in-game addon. Guild Vault imports characters through a Battle.net link. Guild Manager does not offer Battle.net import for WoW Forever today.
- Which tools let officers run DKP loot auctions from Discord?
- Guild Manager (Core) lets officers start, award, reverse, relist, reopen, hand over and close auctions from Discord. CoGM lists “Loot auctions in Discord” on its Pro plan for WoW Forever. Guild Vault lists loot auctions with Discord bot automation on Premium.
- When do WoW Forever raids start?
- Blizzard's launch is November 4, 2026 at 3:00 p.m. PST, and the first raids, Barrow Deeps (10 players) and Hyjal Summit (20 players), unlock on December 9, 2026. Guild Manager's raid signups for both sizes are ready before launch.